When someone lies, it is usually to purposefully lead another towards a different direction. There are many forms of lying, ranging from making a false statement, to changing the spin and telling the 'partial truth'. Lying also ranges in degree, from what is considered the white lie, which arguably keeps the world running, to deceit and trickery seen in swindlers and in the girls of The Crucible. Lying is prominent throughout the piece, and the art of lying is mastered by almost all of the girls, leading to a snowballing of lies and deceits that ended with condemnations and executions.
Most of the characters in The Crucible lie to keep their secrets hidden, their purposes fulfilled, or simply to themselves about the gravity of the situation. Abigail lies about her ability to see spirits, ghosts, the supernatural in general, and the other girls join in on this. This is of course the main instigator to the conflict, and so is detestably the biggest lie told in the play. Proctor lies about cheating on his wife, and then lies again by hiding it. Another important lie that is told is that of the judge, the lieutenant governor, and the minister. They lie not to others, but to themselves; their pride causes them to lie about serving God's justice. Ironically, lying actually saves the lives of many of the condemned, since by lying, you were renouncing your 'witchery' and could go to God again. On the other hand of this, telling the truth got you killed, and no matter how strong your integrity is after your death, you're still dead. So would it be better to lie and live or tell the truth and die?
I really liked the visual you included in your blog. I also like how took a multi-faceted view on the art of lying.
ReplyDeleteI like how you ended you blog with another open ended question. It really causes me to think about what you've wrote. I also like how you discussed how the judges were lying to themselves to help save their pride. They couldn't admit they made a mistake with the trials, so they lived in a false reality to trick themselves into thinking they were right.
ReplyDeleteYou construct a good argument on the realities of lying. On one hand, you lie and live; on the other hand, you tell the truth and live. In the Crucible, Miller shows how theocracy, that is the fusion of church and state, change society. Christianity tells these individuals in society that all their actions and thoughts result in their final destination in either Heaven or Hell. So answering your question, it depends on whether you believe in an afterlife; it depends on whether you believe in your own integrity; and it depends on how you want to go out (how you want to die... in your own terms or in someone else's)?
ReplyDelete